Meet Our Team

Meet the team driven by the desire to protect what matters most to you.

Home » About O’Neill Insurance » Meet Our Team

Contact our Team

To reach the main office, please call (330) 334-1561 and our administrative assistant will be happy to serve you. Or, contact your advisor using the direct dial or email information listed on this page.

Want to work with a team like this?

We’re Hiring!
Kristen Baughman

Kristen Baughman
Commercial Account Assistant

330-849-5229

Jordan Bennett

Jordan Bennett
Group Benefits Account Manager

(330) 849-5236

Lori Bennett

Lori Bennett
Controller / Life Specialist / Medicare Supplement Insurance Advisor

330-331-7954

Jill Buie

Jill Buie
Commercial Account Manager

330-849-5234

Kristin Carraway

Kristin Carraway
Administrative Assistant

330-334-1561

Vickie Cepik

Vickie Cepik
Personal Account Manager

330-849-5218

Sarah Clark

Sarah Clark
Commercial Account Manager

(330) 849-5237

Megan Gray

Megan Gray
Commercial Account Manager

330-849-5231

Barb Guth

Barb Guth
Commercial Account Manager

330-849-5232

Sara Longfellow

Sara Longfellow
Personal Account Manager

330-849-5217

Jody Maibach

Jody Maibach
Chief Operating Officer

330-331-7953

Nick Messam

Nick Messam
Commercial Risk Advisor

(330) 849-5230

Julie Nelson

Julie Nelson
Administrative Assistant

330-334-1561

Pat O'Neill

Pat O’Neill
President

330-331-7960

Patrick O'Neill

Patrick O’Neill
Chief Executive Officer

330-331-7951

Stefanie Osborne

Stefanie Osborne
Personal Account Assistant

330-849-5216

Jason Robinson

Jason Robinson
Risk Advisor

330-849-5224

Kathy Smith

Kathy Smith
Personal Account Manager

330-849-5241

Katie Van Zile

Katie Van Zile
Personal Account Manager

(330) 849-5211

Jane Wyatt

Jane Wyatt
Personal Account Manager

330-849-5212

O’Neill Insurance is an independent insurance agency made up of exceptional, passionate people focused on protecting you from the unexpected.

Insurance Quote Request

As an independent agency, we offer multiple options at competitive prices.